The chair was quickly dubbed the "amber throne" after photographs of it began circulating online.
Although Nawrocki presented the gift in June, the news was kept from the public for months, private broadcaster TVN24 reported.
Even officials at Poland's foreign ministry and the Polish embassy in Washington were unaware of the unusual present, according to media reports.
Poland's political landscape is increasingly shaped by a bitter power struggle between Prime Minister Donald Tusk's pro-European government and Nawrocki, a conservative aligned with the Eurosceptic opposition and an ally of Trump.
"I would rather see Poland's relations with the US built on substantive policies rather than political showmanship," Energy Minister Miłosz Motyka said.
"If this amber throne helps Poland secure a clear commitment from the White House to establish a permanent US military base on Polish soil—and at a lower cost—then President Nawrocki might as well throw in a crown for good measure," he added.
Motyka said symbolic gestures mattered, but a strong partnership with the United States must rest on "something more substantial."
(mo/gs)
Click on the audio player above for a report by Michał Owczarek